The Amish might live in a very different way from most of us, but we can all agree on one thing – they know their baked goods! When New Jerseyans go looking for Amish food, they might be more likely to head to the massive community in Pennsylvania, but you don’t have to leave the Garden State to get great Amish baked goods. Tucked away in the small South Jersey town of Mullica Hill, you’ll find a massive farmer’s market and supermarket featuring dozens of vendors, a full-service restaurant – and a classic bakery serving up the best cinnamon rolls in New Jersey. These massive beasts are perfect for sharing – or for devouring all on your own, if you’re in the mood. So enter the market and discover why Beiler’s Bakery has developed a fanbase that crosses state lines!
As soon as you see the horse and buggy on the sign in Mullica Hill, you know you’re at South Jersey’s best Amish market.
Google Maps
One of the highlights is definitely the outpost of Beiler’s Bakery, an iconic Pennsylvania-based Amish bakery serving up a massive selection of desserts.
The Mullica Hill Amish Market/Facebook
You’ll find all your favorite traditional pies, as well as some Amish specialties like the sweet molasses-based Shoofly Pie.
Amish Market at Mullica Hill
Of course, you’ll find whoopie pies - those famous, hand-held sandwich cookies holding a rich layer of buttercream.
The Mullica Hill Amish Market/Facebook
The highlight at Beiler’s, though, has to be the massive trays of cinnamon rolls - coming in pull-apart form for ideal sharing or snacking.
The Mullica Hill Amish Market/Facebook
You can get these delicious beasts in their classic version, frosted, or topped with nuts or raisins - and you never know what they’re cooking up next.
Amish Market at Mullica Hill
If all that exploring makes you work up an appetite, the Amish market now has a full-service restaurant on site as well.
The Mullica Hill Amish Market/Facebook
The reasonably-priced menu features Amish classics and specials like this pineapple-glazed ham loaf.
The Mullica Hill Amish Market/Facebook
Have you visited the Mullica Hill Amish Market for its famous cinnamon rolls? Tell us about your visit, and let us know your pick for the best cinnamon rolls in New Jersey in the comments section! If you’re interested in visiting for yourself, you can check out the market’s website and Facebook page for all the details on the vendors and specials. For another New Jersey hidden gem, check out this riverside fish shack.
Google Maps
The Mullica Hill Amish Market/Facebook
Amish Market at Mullica Hill
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
Address: Mullica Hill Amish Market, 108 Swedesboro Rd, Mullica Hill, NJ 08062, USA
